Like
any other show, Trek has made lots of film mistakes. Some are editing
errors, others gaffes that slopped through post production. I’ve watched
hours and hours…and hours of Trek and have seen some of these episodes a
million times. Making the little mistakes that pop up even more fun.
Especially when you didn’t see them until they were pointed out (thank
you Nitpicker’s Guides!).
Now by mistakes, I don’t mean continuity flubs
like forgetting that you can’t beam someone through shields or
something. I mean honest filming errors you can see on screen, which
were never caught or corrected.
In a previous article on Back to the Future II, I asked why it was necessary for Marty to get the almanac back so fast, didn’t he have all the time in the world? One commenter pointed out, not really. Yeah true the longer Biff had it the bigger the damage. Fair enough. A movie like this is so much fun because of nitpicking apart the little plot holes and inconsistencies. It’s even better because of how tight the writing is. I have my own theories to these plot holes, and thought it would be fun to share them. Course I am just a fan and this is all 100% opinion. There are others smarter and wiser that can breakdown these nits, and others, much more thoroughly than I. This is all in fun.
For this to work, no alternate time lime nonsense since that’s getting convoluted. It’s also an easy answer, and what fun is that? Let’s assume everything happens on the same linear time line. And I did a rant already on why Clara from BTTF III not dying in the ravine would have been a huge screw up to the tine line, so I will spare you that one. I am simply taking ten common BTTF arguments and giving my two sense.
Why Doesn’t Doc Know He Will End up in the Old West?
It’s clear in these movies that the changes don’t happen in the time line until someone makes the change. Like how Marty was never in the old west until he actually went there. Or how George and Lorraine were changed after Marty went to 1955. One question that often comes up is, how do you explain 1955 Doc learning about his fate in the old west, but 1985 Doc doesn’t see it coming?. I always had a theory that he did know what it was going to happen and had to let it play out. The last we see of Doc in BBTF II is him struggling to get the time machine under control. A car he could have landed right away but didn’t. Then it took him seven months to write the letter and get it to Western Union. Why? Because he knew Marty was going to get it and the date of the letter because he read it himself. I think he knew what was going to happen and let history run its course. We know this Doc was altered by the events in the first movie because he wore the bullet proof vest. That means his 1955 counterpart did read Marty’s letter, the same counterpart who would read Doc’s letter from the past. Some say Doc taught himself how to build the time machine, and that seems logical to some degree. The one thing that hurts this argument is when in 1885 Doc has no idea why Marty is wearing the silly cowboy outfit 1955 Doc had him in. But we can chalk that up to him simply forgetting.
