One of my favorite regular
articles was my sitcom face-off’s where I paired two sitcoms together
to see which was better. I haven’t done one of these in ages. Why?
Because I ran out of shows. I had a rule of doing one show one time, and
I simply ran out of shows and/or matches. However, one show I love that
I never did was The Big Bang Theory. I was waiting for it to end, and
am still kinda waiting. Until May 16th anyway. But i think the time has
come to finally give this show some attention. But what to match it to? I
have argued it could be a “Friends” rip off but haven’t I talked enough
about that show? I needed another good show which matched up enough to
compare them. It took awhile, seriously, but I finally remembered a
great ensemble show which does kind of match. So let’s have a face off
with :
VS
It’s no secret which one I liked more than the other here, but I
promise to be fair with this analysis. As always, this is just opinion
and for fun. The office premiered in 2005 and was on until 2013. The Big
Bang Theory premiered in 2007 and is wrapping up this year. These shows
have pro’s, and some major con’s, but which is better?
CATEGORY 1:Michael Scott vs Sheldon Cooper
Sheldon and Michael are surprisingly similar characters. They both
refuse to accept the effects that their actions have on others. With
Michael, it’s his sense of humor which is nonexistent. But don’t tell
him that. With Sheldon, it’s his total lack of social graces and his
insistence that people do and act how he thinks they should. They both
had lonely childhoods with no friends. But where Sheldon decided he
didn’t need friends, Michael craves them. So much so that he does
everything he can to be the most popular person in the room, even if it
hurts others. So who is the better character? Well as I’ve said before.
Michael Scott pissed me off. I just couldn’t like him in a “love to
hate” way because it never felt like he learned anything. And when he
did realize people didn’t react the way he wanted, he would pout about
it. Sheldon was a little more open minded to the fact that there were
rules about “social conventions” he may not be aware of. He would accept
it when he was explained why things he said were wrong, and if he
wronged a friend he would apologize. Plus as the series went on he tried
to do better, even getting married eventually. I know Michael would
marry and move away but did his character ever really evolve? The reason
both these characters work is because you know there is a real person
underneath the obnoxious stuff who does care for his friends. I just
think it comes across a little better with Sheldon then with Michael. I
know people might think I should have compared Dwight to Sheldon, and
there are similarities but honestly think Dwight is all on his own. He
craves authority and that’s all he knows, Sheldon craves knowledge. More
on him below.
WINNER-THE BIG BANG THEORY